He's way off on the Tatum stuff, Alexa was supernatural and the witches were, well Witches. She's neither of them despite having the darker look.
His Trick comment isn't even particularly wrong tbh. It's the old adage of 'It's not what you said, it's the way that you said it.' Yeah he isn't very good but context is key, he's been doing this for what..2 years give or take? He's "fine" but he has that charisma which you can't teach and the ring work will come with time.